Wednesday, February 24, 2021
Home Israel Tar disaster: The court revoked the restraining order on the details of...

Tar disaster: The court revoked the restraining order on the details of the investigation


After hearing the request of Globes and other media outlets, Judge Dr. Ziad Fallah, decided to revoke the publication order regarding the investigation into the tar disaster, and set more limited restrictions on the media outlets dealing with the issue.

“After considering all the considerations and striking the right balance between the various interests, I order – the order issued by yesterday, revoked. I prohibit the publication of any matter concerning the methods of investigation, the factors involved in conducting the investigation, and any details originating in the investigation authority, “I forbid the publication of more ship names than those published, until tomorrow, February 24, at 4:00 PM,” Falah stated.

Article link https://www.news1.news/news/2021/02/tar-disaster-the-court-revoked-the-restraining-order-on-the-details-of-the-investigation.html

- Advertisement -

The judge added that he allows the publication of any detail that originates in an independent investigation conducted by the media, and that does not originate in any investigative authority. He said, “Media investigations can assist the investigating authorities in carrying out their work and should not be seen as a matter that could interfere with the commission of the offense.

“Although I forbade the media to publish anything that originated in the investigative authority, I allow the investigative authorities to use the details that came up in the independent investigations of the media. Article link https://www.news1.news/news/2021/02/tar-disaster-the-court-revoked-the-restraining-order-on-the-details-of-the-investigation.html

The investigative authorities can be fed by the investigations of the media, in order to promote their investigation.”

Yesterday, Globes, other media outlets and the journalists’ organization asked the court to remove or reduce the restraining order regarding the investigation into the tar disaster. This, after the court granted the request of the Ministry of Environmental Protection to impose a total ban on all details of the affair, including every detail that could identify the suspects, including the name of the vessel, ports of departure and destination, cargo and shipping lane.

About a week ago, a large-scale ecological disaster struck the shores of Israel; Tar was ejected to the beach over 170 km, from Rosh Hanikra to Ashkelon, and significantly contaminated habitats, leading to the deaths of animals, leaving damage on rocky and sandy beaches.

Article link https://www.news1.news/news/2021/02/tar-disaster-the-court-revoked-the-restraining-order-on-the-details-of-the-investigation.html

The source of the tar is most likely oil or fuel oil spilled from a ship on February 11, about 50 km off the coast of Israel, according to an initial inspection by the Ministry of Environmental Protection. At this stage, about 10 ships were spotted when one or more may be Suspected as responsible for the serious incident that befell Israel.

Over the past few days, thousands of volunteers across Israel have mobilized to help authorities address the hazard, and clear the tar from the shore. At the same time, the Ministry of Health has informed the general public not to reach the beaches for bathing, sports and leisure activities – until further notice, as exposure to tar can be harmful to health.

Despite the great interest of the public and the economic burden that fell on the shoulders of the taxpayer who at the time had to finance the evacuation of the hazard as there is no information regarding the hazards, the Ministry of Environmental Protection decided not to share information about the affair at this stage.

At the beginning of the hearing, the lawyer Yoni Shamir, who represents the Ministry of Environmental Protection, asked to leave the sweeping publication order as it is, since he said that any publication of an individual concerning the investigation or to whom the investigation relates may harm the Ministry of Defense’s efforts to track down the suspects. . He said, “Petitioners want a transparent investigation. I have been in the field of enforcement for many years. A transparent criminal investigation, this is a request that has internal contradictions. Moreover, they come in a wavy bristle and say ‘key suspects.’ “.

When asked by Judge Zayed Fallah how the current investigation differs from other cases in which investigations are being conducted, Shamir replied that this is an exceptional case. He said, “This investigation is different from ordinary environmental investigations, all the more so in an environmental investigation. This is not some kind of crime scene where a situation can be frozen. Article link https://www.news1.news/news/2021/02/tar-disaster-the-court-revoked-the-restraining-order-on-the-details-of-the-investigation.html

The suspects are not here and it is not easy to track them. Article link https://www.news1.news/news/2021/02/tar-disaster-the-court-revoked-the-restraining-order-on-the-details-of-the-investigation.html

The consequences of that act, we are experiencing here in the form of a very serious catastrophe, of which we still do not know what the long-term consequences will be. This is an international investigation, involving law enforcement agencies around the world. Every information leak, every publicity – “It has serious implications. Article link https://www.news1.news/news/2021/02/tar-disaster-the-court-revoked-the-restraining-order-on-the-details-of-the-investigation.html

The publications, some of which were in violation of the order, hampered the investigation.”

Judge Fallah wondered why the Ministry of Environmental Protection was reminded to apply for a restraining order this week, and not immediately after the event was published on Wednesday, after details were published in the media. Shamir said that “even if there is information that the public has been exposed to, it does not mean that the information leakage can not be stopped. Article link https://www.news1.news/news/2021/02/tar-disaster-the-court-revoked-the-restraining-order-on-the-details-of-the-investigation.html

The investigation is in its infancy,” referring to the publication of journalist Yoav Zehavi last night on News 11 Article link https://www.news1.news/news/2021/02/tar-disaster-the-court-revoked-the-restraining-order-on-the-details-of-the-investigation.html

The Ministry of Environmental Protection from the court to immediately approve a sweeping publication ban order.

During the hearing, Judge Fallah asked representatives of the Ministry of Environmental Protection to submit to him a note detailing the investigative actions requiring a restraining order. After receiving the note, the judge said, “If you had written this to me yesterday, I would not have allowed you a seven-day restraining order.”

At the request of the Ministry of Environmental Protection to detail how the publications hit behind closed doors, the judge refused. Without fully elaborating on the circumstances, Shamir claimed that “Here 11” contacted a company linked to one of the ships, and received its version. In this way, a suspect can understand that we are closing in on his footsteps and the craft of gathering evidence becomes more difficult. This is not a blanket order, but a seven-day order to track down the evidence. “

Lawyer Orian Eshkoli Yahalom, representing Globes, argued at the hearing that it was puzzling that the Ministry of Environmental Protection demanded a restraining order, after he himself published details regarding the investigation on Saturday, after issuing a press release announcing the progress of the investigation, the location of the possible hazard. . She added, “After the announcement by the Ministry of Environmental Protection, journalists came to the information themselves, and published it. It is a little embarrassing that we have to come and say in court that these things are allowed to be published, which did not come from the investigation itself.” It’s puzzling that the claim came from the other side. “

Amir Basha, who serves as a friend of the court on behalf of the journalists’ organization, said that “the details regarding the detainees and potential detainees are already known all over the world, including the ship’s name, origin and sailing routes. This is a comprehensive order, when there is a public interest in its cancellation. Article link https://www.news1.news/news/2021/02/tar-disaster-the-court-revoked-the-restraining-order-on-the-details-of-the-investigation.html

The Ministry of Environmental Protection has not presented an infrastructure regarding how the investigation is harmed. Article link https://www.news1.news/news/2021/02/tar-disaster-the-court-revoked-the-restraining-order-on-the-details-of-the-investigation.html

The fish and citizens in Israel are the only ones who do not know the details of the case. Article link https://www.news1.news/news/2021/02/tar-disaster-the-court-revoked-the-restraining-order-on-the-details-of-the-investigation.html

The Honorable Court will revoke the restraining order. “

Extensive ecological disaster

About a week ago, a large-scale ecological disaster struck Israel’s shores: Tar was ejected to the beach over 170 km, from Rosh Hanikra to Ashkelon, and significantly contaminated habitats, leading to animal deaths and leaving damage on rocky and sandy beaches.

Article link https://www.news1.news/news/2021/02/tar-disaster-the-court-revoked-the-restraining-order-on-the-details-of-the-investigation.html

The source of the tar is probably oil or fuel oil spilled from a ship on February 11, about 50 km off the coast of Israel, according to an initial inspection by the Ministry of Environmental Protection. At this point, about 10 ships that passed by were located, with one or more suspects responsible. To the serious incident that befell Israel.

Over the past few days, thousands of volunteers across Israel have mobilized to help authorities deal with the hazard and clear the tar from the shore. At the same time, the Ministry of Health has informed the general public not to go to the beaches for bathing, sports and recreational activities – until further notice, as exposure to tar can be harmful to health.

Despite the great interest in the public and the economic burden that fell on the shoulders of the taxpayer who was forced to finance the evacuation of the hazard, as there is no information regarding the hazards, the Ministry of Environmental Protection decided not to share information with the public at this stage.




Important Alert

Dear reader.
I hope you are in health and well.
I offer you important instructions regarding this article

  • We only want readers to access information quickly and easily using other multilingual content, rather than information only available in a specific language.
  • We always respect the copyright of the author's content and always include
    the original link of the Source Article , and if the author does not agree, leave the report below the article, the article will be edited or deleted at the author's request. Thank you so much! Warm greetings!


.

Source link
https://www.globes.co.il/news/article.aspx?did=1001361654


LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -

Most Popular

Recent Comments