The ruling: “Law violates Palestinian property rights and equality”
The Supreme Court, in the grounds of the sentence arrived with 8 votes in favor and only one against, explained that the 2017 law, which affects approx 4 thousand homes built by settlers in the West Bank, “violates i property rights and equality Palestinians while privileging Israeli settlers’ interests over Palestinian residents. ” The law, they point out, does not “provide sufficient relief” to the status of “Palestinians as protected residents in an area under military occupation”.
Specifically, the legal text was supposed to legalize homes built in Jewish settlements on Palestinian private land erected “in good faith” or that had the backing of the Israeli government or whose owners had received 125% financial compensation for the land. In recent years, the court has repeatedly ordered the demolition of houses built in Jewish outposts on Palestinian private land.
Gantz: “We will respect the sentence”. Netanyahu wants reduced annexations
The court’s decision sparked protests from the nationalist right, while it was well received by moderate and leftist parties. The other ‘alternate prime minister’, Benny Gantz, however, stated that “the Court’s decision will be applied” and that his party Blue White “Will ensure that it is respected.” A source close to Netanyahu, cited by the newspaper Haaretzinstead commented that “with the application of sovereignty most of the regularization problems will be solved”, with reference to the annexation plans of the leader of the Likud.
In Netanyahu’s mind, official sources say anonymously and cited by Times of Israel, there is the idea of coming to the conclusion of one first small phase of annexations, to be proposed by July 1compared to the broader peace plan proposed by Trump, which would involve the three largest and oldest Jewish settlements: Ma’ale Adumim, Gush Etzion is Ariel, excluding the Jordan Valley so as not to feed tensions with the neighbor Jordan who already opposed the plans Tel Aviv.
The Foreign Minister, Gabi Ashkenazi, a member of Blu Bianco, during a press conference with his German counterpart, Heiko Maas, however, specified that “we are at the beginning of the discussions, no decision has been made (on annexations, ed). When it is taken we will give the details. ” While declaring that for his party, Trump’s plan represents “a significant opportunity” to be pursued “responsibly”.
The annexation plan however provoked harsh protests in the country, with thousands of Israelis, including the famous singer Noa, who participated in a demonstration against Israeli occupation of the Palestinian Territories in Tel Aviv’s Rabin Square. The police have arrested 12 people which, according to the official version, had “hindered traffic”. Among the arrested too Tomer Appelbaum, a photographer of Haaretz who was resuming the agents’ behavior.
Germany: “Serious concern about annexation plan”
During the press conference with the Israeli minister, however, Maas expressed the sentiment of “Serious concern” of the government of Berlin on the annexation plan in the West Bank. “As friends of Israel, we are very concerned about the annexation, which does not reconcile with international law – he said – We continue to support the two-state solution. A creative push is needed to revive the negotiations “.
There Germany it is only the latest, internationally, to express concern. Among the first there had been, in addition to the representatives of thePalestinian National Authority and to the countries of the area, such as Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Turkey and also there Russia, the High Representative for EU foreign policy, Josep Borrell, who speaking on behalf of the EU had declared: “We will not recognize the annexation of the colonies”. Words that had provoked the response of the Foreign Minister who spoke of “Megaphone diplomacy”.
Moscow, with the Kremlin envoy for the Middle East, Mikhail Bogdanov, said that, in their view, the Israeli plan to annex areas of the West Bank, if implemented, will kill the two-state solution and is likely to cause one new escalation of violence in the area.
Words similar to those spoken by the PLO secretary general, Saeb Erekat: “Benjamin Netanyahu will destroy the Palestinian National Authority” at a time when “peace is needed”, he told the newspaper Ynet, adding that the prime minister “is destroying the path towards a two-state solution”.
Palestinian Premier: “With annexations we will declare the state of Palestine”
The Palestinian Prime Minister, Mohammed Shtayyeh, is not there and declared that, in the event of unilateral annexation, “from interim institution, the PNA will pass to a state demonstration on the ground with a Board of Foundation, a constitutive declaration. Palestine will extend along the 1967 borders with capital Jerusalem. We will ask for international recognition, the world will choose between international law and annexation. ”
“The annexation – he added – is one existential threat, a serious violation of the agreements, the total breakdown of international law, a challenge to stability. It means the destruction of the perspective of a Palestinian state. If we accepted it, we would be a bunch of traitors. ”